ALEXANDRIA, VA — The arrest of Harvard Professor Henry Louis
Gates, Jr., for disorderly conduct after a 911 call reported an apparent
break-in at his Cambridge, Massachusetts, home has led many observers
to tell us that the idea of a “post-racial” society is
a myth and that racism is alive and well.
The charges have been dropped, and Gates and the arresting officer,
Sgt. James Crowley, have visited with President Obama, who, while admitting
he did not know the facts of the case, nevertheless charged that the
police acted “stupidly.” These facts aside, the reaction
is instructive.
Most observers, reviewing the facts calmly, find that, while both
Gates and Crowley may have overreacted, no racism was involved. Crowley,
who has taught a class on racial profiling for five years at the Lowell
Police Academy, was described by his director as a good role model
and was hand-picked by a black police commissioner. When Crowley entered
the house, he made no reference to race. From everything we know,
Gates introduced the subject.
Many prominent black Americans have used this case to tell us that,
the election of President Obama aside, racism is alive and well in
our society. Using a highly ambiguous case in which race seems
to have played no part, they have made light of the tremendous progress
we have made in race relations.
Lawrence Bobo, a professor of the social sciences at Harvard, declared: “Ain’t
nothing post-racial about the United States of America.... If Skip
(Gates) can be arrested on his front porch, there but for the grace
of God goes every other black man in America.... [I]]t should be enough
to end all this post-racial hogwash.”
Massachusetts Governor Deval L. Patrick, who is black, described Gates’ experience
as “Every black man’s nightmare.” Christopher Edley,
Jr., the dean of the University of California at Berkeley Law
School, who is also black, said the Gates incident should dispel “the
rosy hopefulness” of Mr. Obama's election “in case anybody
needed evidence that we’re not beyond race.”
The Rev. Jesse Jackson declared that the Gates incident “is
a stark example that racial profiling knows no boundaries of class,
status, neighborhood, or reputation.... There can be no ‘post-racial’ America
when such glaring racial disparities and incidents of race profiling
continue to permeate all facets of society.”
It appears that many of those who refuse to recognize the dramatic
progress we have made in race relations will use the flimsiest excuse
— such as the Gates case — to declare that America is a “racist” society.
Fortunately, the facts of racial progress speak for themselves. Not
only do we now have a black president, attorney general, and ambassador
to the United Nations — among other cabinet-level posts — but this
is nothing new. In the Bush administration, we had two black secretaries
of state. This is not to say that residual racism does not exist
and that there is no progress yet to be made. It is to say that
it is unseemly to promote the ideas that ours is a hate-filled society. Some
people, it seems, cannot take “yes” for an answer.
Comedian and actor Bill Cosby said he is worried about the direction
of the conversation and urged people “who don’t know” the
facts in a particular case to step back and refrain from commenting
— and extrapolating an isolated and ambiguous incident into an example
of continuing racism.
Fortunately, many black Americans refuse to engage in this racial
game that Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton, and others have been playing
for many years. One of the outstanding black spokesmen for a color-blind
society, in which an individual would be judged on the basis of merit
rather than race, is J.A. (Jay) Parker.
Parker has had a distinguished career. He has been a radio talk
show host, a leader in Young Americans for Freedom (YAF), an active
opponent of the spread of Marxism in Africa as a leader in the American
African Affairs Association, and the founder and President of the Lincoln
Institute for Research and Education. The Lincoln Institute has for
many years urged the creation of a genuinely color-blind society and
argued that our free enterprise system is the best path for racial
progress.
In l980, Parker was named to head President Ronald Reagan’s
transition team at the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (this
writer was a member of that team and has been a close associate of
Jay Parker for many years). Its final report declared: “The
goal of all Americans of good will should be the creation of a society
which is both color-blind and committed to economic growth and advancement. A
system of racial quotas and classifications in a declining economy
is the prescription for inter-group tensions and social dislocation. It
violates our basic principles of individual freedom and our hope for
continuing progress.”
During the Reagan years, Parker worked with the U.S. Information Agency
to help project a more accurate view of America. He also worked with
Attorney General Edwin Meese III on a special committee on the problem
of missing and exploited children, as well as with the U. S. Defense
Department as a member of the Army Science Board.
One of Jay’s most important contributions has been his dedication
to such important charities as the Salvation Army, the Columbia Lighthouse
for the Blind, and Goodwill Industries; he served each in a leadership
role. He was president of the Washington, D.C., Kiwanis Club. He
believes in putting his belief in individualism into action because “problems
in America can only truly be fixed by individuals convincing individuals,
one at a time, how to behave properly.”
When this writer spoke at a dinner honoring Jay on his 70th birthday,
I quoted a line of Whoopie Goldberg’s. When Goldberg expressed
her interest in a Hollywood career, one of her friends tried to discourage
her, telling her that, “You know you’re black.” Goldberg
responded, “I won't mention it.” This was a clear
expression of Jay’s philosophy.
A new book, Courage To Put Country above Color, about the life of
Jay Parker has been written by David W. Tyson and is available free
to readers. (Those who would like to receive a copy should write
to The Lincoln Review Letter, P.O. Box 254, l03l5 Georgetown Pike,
Great Falls, VA 22066-24l5).
In the foreword, former Attorney General Meese writes that, “Jay
Parker was an influential leader who joined with President Reagan and
me to help ensure the enactment of the Reagan Revolution... As a result
of Jay’s efforts, America began to step away from the Carter
administration’s reliance on racial quotas and move toward President
Reagan's vision of a truly color-blind society.”
Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas has stated: “Jay
is the most principled person I have met in Washington.... I know that
I wouldn’t be on the court if I had not met Jay Parker.”
When we discuss the state of race relations in America, it is important
to remember that the voices of those who promote the idea that racism
is alive and well and widespread — as in the reaction to the Henry
Louis Gates case — are not the only black voices to be heard. Others,
such as Jay Parker, have devoted their lives to making our country
a genuinely free, open, and inclusive society. In great measure, it
is they who have succeeded.
The Conservative Curmudgeon archives
The Conservative Curmudgeon is copyright © 2009
by Allan C. Brownfeld and the Fitzgerald
Griffin Foundation.
All rights reserved. Editors may use this column if this copyright information
is included.
Allan C. Brownfeld is the author of five books, the latest of which
is The Revolution Lobby (Council for Inter-American Security). He has
been a staff aide to a U.S. Vice President, Members of Congress, and
the U.S. Senate Internal Subcommittee.
He is associate editor of The Lincoln Reveiw and a contributing
editor to such publications as Human Events,
The St. Croix Review, and The Washington Report on Middle
East Affairs.
The Fitzgerald Griffin Foundation needs your help to continue making
these columns available. To make a tax-deductible donation, click
here.