MINOT, NORTH DAKOTA — The first presidential debate that put
“Big Bird” in the news also helped to put in perspective the challenge
of reining in federal spending before it irreversibly bankrupts our
Governor Romney said that as president he would eliminate federal
subsidies to programs such as the Public Broadcasting System (PBS).
“I’m going to stop the subsidy to PBS. I’m going to stop other things.
I like PBS, I love Big Bird. But I’m not going to keep on spending
money on things we borrow money from China to pay for,” he said.
President Obama has called this proposal irresponsible. LeVar Burton,
long-time host of PBS’s “Reading Rainbow,” was incensed. Mr. Burton
said, “I am personally outraged that any serious contender for the
White House would target as part of his campaign the children of America
in this fashion.”
I am sure that Mr. Barton’s outrage has nothing to do with the fact
that taxpayers fund his salary. Yet it should trouble everyone when
such a celebrity uses incendiary language such as “targeting” children
to attack anyone who points out the unnecessary spending of those dollars.
Mr. Burton states, “Educators across the country, as well as millions
of children and adults, know that the programming on PBS has been responsible
for significant improvements in education, literacy, math, science,
and life skills for generations of our children.”
Sadly, it is simply false that American education has seen “significant
improvement in education, literacy, math, science, and life skills
for generations of our children.” The opposite is all too true. Yet,
Mr. Burton is using taxpayer funding to spread false propaganda regarding
Perhaps his most distorted statement is, “PBS represents .00016 percent
of our nation’s budget, yet this free resource benefits kids across
all economic circumstances.” PBS is not a free resource — it receives
approximately $455 million of taxpayer funding annually, of which $5.7
million goes to Sesame Street.
The problem with those who expect taxpayers to give them money is
their lack of understanding that those taxpayers have to work hard
to earn that money and then have to do without it. Suggesting that
it is “free” or an insignificant part of our work effort should outrage
every one of us.
For each of the last four years, the federal deficit has exceeded
$1 trillion, including dollars used to fund hundreds of thousands of
programs like PBS. This deficit spending is a hidden future tax. It
is not free. Rather, it is a claim on our future earnings to pay for
unnecessary current spending.
Mr. Burton’s comments illustrate the thinking that permeates today’s
culture. The Mr. Burtons of the world view other people’s earnings
and future earnings as something they have a right to claim. And they
think it is appropriate to attack anyone who challenges this thinking.
Every dollar the government spends is a dollar our families must do
without. Deficit spending accounts for one out of every three dollars
the federal government spends. And it must be repaid — not dollar
for dollar but with interest added.
The only way to save our country, reduce our debt, and control a
government that has grown out of control is to cut thousands and thousands
of “free” programs like PBS.
If Mr. Burton’s comments are illustrative of “significant improvement
in education, literacy, math, science and life skills,” I suggest defunding
PBS is not only fiscally prudent; it is absolutely necessary.
Massive debt like that of the United States comes from the irresponsible
spending of one dollar at a time. A whopping $5,760,000 tax dollars
going to PBS is neither insignificant nor free. It is the total annual
income of more than 150 families. It is time to begin the huge job
of cutting the spending of the equivalent of more than 200,000 such
programs. This is what it will take to eliminate our deficit spending.
We can either begin to reduce the deficits now, or we can ignore the
problem and let our creditors do it. By the way, our three biggest
creditors are China, Japan, and Saudi Arabia
A Voice from Fly-Over
A Voice from Fly-Over Country is copyright © 2011
by Robert L. Hale and the Fitzgerald
All rights reserved.
Robert L. Hale received his J.D. in law from Gonzaga University Law
School in Spokane, Washington. He is founder and director of a non-profit
public interest law firm. For more than three decades he has been involved
in drafting proposed laws and counseling elected officials in ways
to remove burdensome and unnecessary rules and regulations.
See a complete biographical sketch.
To subscribe or donate to the FGF E-Package online or
send a check to:
P.O. Box 1383
Vienna, VA 22183